Jul 09

The choir doesn’t have the sheet music.

Garry-Opatut family
On May 12, my partner and I had a civil union ceremony in our New Jersey home. It was small but felt very big. Just our family. After 24 years together, we finally have a legitimate anniversary.

But like many things in life, there has been a ripple effect. The comments and reactions of our friends, gay and straight – those who consider themselves progressive – were a wake up call to us.

“Now, you’re married – just like us,” our straight married friends say with a big smile. We correct them. Over and over and over again. We talk about the difference between state and federal protections. We talk about not sharing social security protections and inheritance. And then we wait for the “aha.” They do not disappoint. Their jaws drop and then you see a hint of embarrassment that they didn’t know. Outrage follows.

What the hell is going on? How can we ever hope to change hearts and minds when our own choir doesn’t have the sheet music?

My partner was part of the management team that launched LOGO, Viacom’s lgbt channel. She loves that LOGO is a basic cable network and that reaches both gay and straight. But she often found herself educating even her gay colleagues in the offices and cubicles around her. For young staff members, it was often a lack of understanding of our movement’s history along with a certain complacency. For straight staff members it was often the reality of second-class citizenship. She’d come home wide-eyed and upset. Eileen was handing out sheet music to folks who should have known the song by heart.

I saw another example of this last week – this time on the editorial page of The Washington Post. “The Sky Isn’t Falling,” the Post proclaims. The Post points to a change in public opinion and the fact that the opposition in Massachusetts could not rally its troops to get sufficient votes to put a referendum on the 2008 ballot to amend the state constitution to pre-empt marriage rights for same sex couples. It’s a great piece with an alarming twist. The editor neglected to check the paper’s own Style Guide that clearly states that the words ‘gay and lesbian’ are to be used instead of the clinical and dehumanizing “homosexual.” Good intention that ultimately reinforces what the opposition loves – to refer to us with one of their favorite words. The one they believe implies disorder.

During my decade of service as the executive director of GLAAD, I spoke a lot about reaching the swing middle – the most influential Americans who are on the fence about us. We call them “moveable.” But we will only move them if we educate them. And ourselves.

Maybe we have misled people into thinking we have things we don’t really have. Maybe we haven’t been smart enough with the media. Maybe it’s not easy to tell a progressive they don’t know everything. There are a lot of ‘maybes’ but one thing I know for sure. The lgbt community has got to work harder. We have got to get the facts straight. We’ve got to educate ourselves so that we can arm our friends and allies with the facts they need to go to bat for us. We can take absolutely nothing for granted.

Eileen and I found ourselves arming our own kids with the facts as we planned for our ceremony. We had to tell them that this is not really what everyone else has. They were stunned but they got it. Kit spoke at our service:

“This isn’t really considered marriage but this is what we’ve got.”

GLAAD will no doubt reach out to The Washington Post for its violation of its own style guide. But who among us will take responsibility for the well-intentioned and the ill-informed? For those who stand with us in their hearts and in theory but can’t make the case on our behalf? And what about members of our own community?

The straightest thing about us better be our facts.

17 Responses to “The choir doesn’t have the sheet music.”

  1. Sandee Says:

    To Joan and ‘her Eileen’ (I SO love the way you said that in your ‘Who’s Joan’ video!). I guess a hearty congratulations are in order – but to tell you the truth, I’ve always thought of the two of you as … married. I remember the rings, the trip to Hawaii and even the pictures you took from the helicopter (looking down at the lava - OMG!). That, was a big deal. Also a big deal was when the kids came along. I remember the calls you made home from the apartment on Arista Way. But it’s always been “Joan and ‘her Eileen’” to me. And geez, you guys really DO have a white picket fence, if that’s not married with children, I don’t know what you call it!

    A hearty congratulations and congrats also on v2 of joangarry.com!

    From your not-so-politically-inclined, former subordinate and friend.

    Sandee!

    PS: Also love the hat piece you did – I could follow that one pretty easily. Let’s hear the story about the jock strap and cup next!

  2. George Says:

    I read your article in the blade, I thought it was right on: we should constantly educate or lighter said share our daily and weekly intake of political information regarding glbt. I have just started to include one paragraph of current politics to my father, but even a sentence would do to any e/mail to a friend.

    This is about the politics, and I am optimest that things would change, but the arts… I am yet to read one good film review, Advocate had once three homofobic movies covered in one issue, as gay/lesbian films. I am a film maker, and hard to say but we are the most consevative, anti intelectual and regressive part of the society, especially in fiction films. Filmakers dont seem to have any interest in feminism, black studies, new man-studies, it seems it belongs to a small reunion after the masters or phd seremony, and it seems it would never reach the narrative film.

    I think when it comes to educating our own comunity about the storytelling and the arts, we are just so far away…

  3. mosquito ringtone Says:

    Hey check out my site.. these kind of ringtones cannt be heard by parents and teachers…only by teenagers…

  4. penis enlargement Says:

    No one is here for help all want just money money and money.

  5. Hit counter Says:

    Mony is mony and all we need is mony

  6. penis enlargement Says:

    wow every one want mony mony and mony.

  7. Hoodia Gordonii Says:

    Nothing can stop me by posting these comments.

  8. buy viagra Says:

    All fine plus nine equal to not fine.

  9. Sd card Says:

    Interesting article!
    Thanks

  10. J.D. Says:

    hey, it’s funny u should mention willy wonka and the choclate factory in your college tours - a stroll down memory lane link. the kid in yer pic looks just like the kid in the movie. lol

  11. Free articles Says:

    Nice to play and easy to win but hard to fight.
    http://www.adnarticles.com

  12. Free Articles Says:

    Nice to play and easy to win but hard to fight.
    http://www.adnarticles.com

  13. hair loss Says:

    Nice work and I hope you will keep it up with your efforts. http://hairlosstreatmentx.com

  14. Laser Textile Says:

    Nice post … can u please subscribe me to your newsletter if u have any.
    Thanks - http://www.proel.it

  15. Libido Says:

    Just chill on and enhance your libido for sure success.
    http://www.libido-enhancers.com

  16. Vigrx Says:

    Chill to mill and fill the drill of success with vigrx plus -
    http://www.vigrx-plus.net

  17. SEOZ Says:

    Nine plus nine all fine.
    http://nasrullahmardani.com

Leave a Reply